Cristian Fernandez 12 Year Old Murderer Full Length Police Interrogation

True Crime Podcast 2025 - REAL Police Interrogations, 911 Calls, True Police Stories and True Crime

Cristian Fernandez 12 Year Old Murderer Full Length Police Interrogation

The full-length police interrogation of Cristian Fernandez is one of the most controversial and emotionally charged cases in modern legal history, given the circumstances of the crime, his young age, and the legal debates surrounding it. Cristian Fernandez was just 12 years old when he was charged with first-degree murder for the death of his 2-year-old half-brother, David Galarraga, in Jacksonville, Florida, in 2011.

Key Aspects of Cristian Fernandez’s Police Interrogation

1. The Crime

• Cristian Fernandez was accused of inflicting fatal injuries on his younger brother, David, while they were left unsupervised. The child died from severe head trauma.
• The case drew national attention because of Fernandez's age and the severity of the charges.

2. Cristian’s Age and Vulnerability

• The interrogation is particularly controversial because Cristian was only 12 years old.
• Critics argue that he may not have fully understood his rights or the long-term consequences of his statements during the questioning.

3. Interrogation Tactics

• Police used questioning techniques that were highly scrutinized due to Cristian’s young age.
• The interrogation often appeared intense, with law enforcement seeking details about the incident and his intentions.
• Legal experts have pointed out that minors are particularly vulnerable to coercion or misunderstanding during interrogations.

4. Cristian’s Emotional Responses

• Cristian showed moments of confusion, fear, and sadness during the interrogation.
• His demeanor highlighted the tragic complexity of the case: a child being questioned for the death of another child.

5. Evidence and Confession

• During the interrogation, Cristian reportedly admitted to causing his brother’s injuries but claimed it was not intentional.
• The details provided in his confession became a focal point of the legal case, particularly regarding intent and culpability.

6. Legal and Ethical Controversies

• The case sparked debates about trying juveniles as adults, particularly in cases involving violent crimes.
• Many questioned whether the interrogation was conducted ethically, given Cristian’s age and lack of legal representation during key moments.

Case Outcome

• Initially facing life in prison without parole, Cristian eventually agreed to a plea deal in 2013. He pled guilty to manslaughter and aggravated battery in exchange for an 18-year sentence with a chance for review.

Public and Media Reaction

• The case drew widespread media coverage, with many expressing outrage over the handling of the interrogation and the harshness of the charges against such a young child.
• Advocates for juvenile justice reform cited Cristian’s case as an example of systemic failures in handling minors in the legal system.

Cristian Fernandez, full police interrogation, juvenile justice, child suspect, first-degree murder case, controversial interrogation, coerced confession, juvenile interrogation techniques, child rights in law, manslaughter case, juvenile crime, criminal justice reform, intent vs. accident, emotional vulnerability, head trauma case, child criminal responsibility, plea deal, media scrutiny, legal ethics, juvenile crime controversy.